Can an Indian Court Stop a Divorce Case Abroad? Supreme Court Says Not So Fast (2026 INSC 1034)
Updated: Sep 25
He filed for divorce in Kolkata. She filed for divorce in London. Then an Indian court ordered her to stop the London case altogether. On 22 September 2026, the Supreme Court said that order should never have been passed.
In Mihir Prakash Bajoria vs Vidushi Jain Bajoria (2026 INSC 1034), the Court explained when Indian courts can restrain a spouse from pursuing a divorce abroad, and why that power must be used rarely. For thousands of Indian couples living overseas, this reportable judgment changes how cross-border divorce battles will be fought.
Quick Facts
Case: Mihir Prakash Bajoria vs Vidushi Jain Bajoria
Citation: 2026 INSC 1034 (Reportable), Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 15849 of 2026
Bench: Justice S.V.N. Bhatti and Justice N.V. Anjaria (judgment authored by Justice N.V. Anjaria)
Date: 22 September 2026
Under Challenge: Calcutta High Court Division Bench judgment dated 15.12.2025 in FMAT No. 466 of 2025, which set aside an anti-suit injunction granted by the Civil Judge (Senior Division), Alipore on 01.11.2025
Result: Husband's appeal dismissed. The anti-suit injunction stays vacated.
One Marriage, Two Countries, Two Divorce Cases
The couple's relationship began around 2014-2015 in the UK, where the wife moved for higher studies. They married in Kolkata on 15.12.2018 as per Hindu customs, lived together in London at Academy Gardens from 2018 to 2020, and later returned to India in October 2023. They separated in November 2023, and the wife moved to her parental home in Kolkata.
His case (India): On 04.09.2024, the husband filed Matrimonial Suit No. 2643 of 2024 at Alipore under Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, saying the couple had not cohabited since November 2023.
Her case (UK): On 10.10.2024, the wife filed for divorce before the Central Family Court, UK on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage, along with a claim for interim financial relief.
The UK court ordered interim maintenance and costs on 16.05.2025, appointed a Senior Advocate as a joint expert on Indian law, and took up jurisdiction as a preliminary issue. In India, the wife's plea to stay the husband's divorce case was rejected on 25.09.2025 (her revision is pending, and the matter has been referred to mediation).
The Order That Started the Fight
On 31.10.2025, the husband filed Title Suit No. 1656 of 2025 at Alipore, asking for a declaration that the UK proceedings were vexatious and without jurisdiction. He also claimed Rs. 2.40 crore with 18% interest for amounts paid under UK court orders, including Rs. 85 lakh in legal expenses.
The very next day, 01.11.2025, the Alipore court granted an ex parte anti-suit injunction restraining the wife from pursuing her UK divorce and financial cases. Its reasoning: irretrievable breakdown is not a statutory ground for divorce under Hindu law, so a UK decree on that ground would not be recognised in India under Section 13 of the CPC anyway.
The response from England was swift. On the wife's application, the High Court of Justice, Family Division passed an ex parte order restraining the husband from enforcing or relying on the Indian injunction. On 10.12.2025, the UK Family Court held that the UK was the convenient forum. Five days later, the Calcutta High Court set aside the Indian anti-suit injunction.
What Is an Anti-Suit Injunction? (In Plain English)
An anti-suit injunction is an order by one court telling a party before it to stop pursuing a case in another court, often in another country. An Indian court cannot order a foreign court to stop. It can only order the person who is subject to its own jurisdiction. The Supreme Court endorsed this explanation from the Delhi High Court's ruling in Raaj Unocal Lubricants Ltd. v. Apple Energy Pvt. Ltd.
Relying on Modi Entertainment Network v. W.S.G. Cricket Pte. Ltd., (2003) 4 SCC 341, the Court restated the three basic conditions:
The party to be restrained must be amenable to the personal jurisdiction of the Indian court.
Refusing the injunction must defeat the ends of justice and perpetuate injustice.
The principle of comity of courts must be respected.
The Court added that oppressive or vexatious proceedings and irreparable harm are the twin prime considerations, and that the burden of proving the foreign forum is inconvenient or oppressive lies on the party who claims it.
Why the Supreme Court Refused to Stop the UK Divorce
1. Anti-suit injunctions are the exception, not the rule
The Court said such orders are not a routine judicial exercise and should be granted sparingly, since they effectively interfere with a foreign court's sovereign jurisdiction. Frequent use would undermine comity and create conflicting orders across borders, exactly what happened here when the English court issued a counter-order.
2. The "irretrievable breakdown" argument was premature
The husband argued that a UK decree based on irretrievable breakdown would be unenforceable in India, relying on Y. Narasimha Rao v. Y. Venkata Lakshmi, (1991) 3 SCC 451. The Court called this a misplaced ground at that stage. The UK case was still pending, jurisdiction itself was undecided, and the wife still had to prove her case. An injunction cannot rest on speculation about what a foreign court might eventually decide.
3. Dinesh Singh Thakur applied "by reverse logic"
In Dinesh Singh Thakur v. Sonal Thakur, (2018) 17 SCC 12, a husband had sought to stop his wife's US divorce case based on irretrievable breakdown. The Supreme Court refused, holding that filing on a ground not available under the Hindu Marriage Act does not mean the wife will succeed, and a foreign court cannot be presumed to act wrongly. The Court held that the same law governs this case.
4. London, not Kolkata, was the natural forum
Applying forum non conveniens, with reference to Arif Azim Co. Ltd. v. Micromax Informatics FZE, (2025) 9 SCC 750, the English Spiliada principle and Baksish Ahmad v. Union of India, the Court agreed the UK was the convenient forum. The husband had lived in the UK since the age of 14-15, the wife was a habitual resident there on a student visa, and most of their married life was spent in their London home. Their matrimonial home, centre of interests and financial arrangements were all in the UK.
5. You cannot stop a case that has not even finished
The Court held that the Alipore court committed a patent error by ignoring that the UK proceedings were still at an inchoate stage. When a foreign case has not reached a final decision, there is generally no legitimate reason to halt it through an anti-suit injunction.
The Twist: A UK Divorce Decree While the Appeal Was Pending
While the case was before the Supreme Court, District Judge Shorthose at the Birmingham Civil and Family Justice Centre passed a conditional divorce order on 17.06.2026. On the husband's application, the Supreme Court on 30.07.2026 restrained the wife from proceeding on that order.
In its final judgment, however, the Court confined itself to the validity of the 01.11.2025 anti-suit injunction. It expressed no opinion on the UK conditional divorce order, left both parties free to challenge any further or final UK orders before the competent forum, and held that pending interlocutory applications did not survive once the appeal was dismissed.
Does This Mean Foreign Divorces on Irretrievable Breakdown Are Valid in India?
Not necessarily, and this is where the debate lies. The judgment does not decide whether a UK divorce decree on irretrievable breakdown will be recognised in India. That question arises under Section 13 of the CPC and Y. Narasimha Rao only after a foreign decree is passed and someone seeks to rely on it.
Critics will say this leaves Indian spouses exposed to expensive foreign litigation, maintenance orders and a decree that may later turn out to be unenforceable at home. Supporters will say it respects where couples actually built their lives, and stops Indian courts from blocking foreign proceedings based on guesswork. Either way, the message is clear: challenge the foreign decree when it comes, not the foreign case while it runs.
What This Means for NRI Couples and Family Lawyers
Filing first in India does not automatically let you stop a spouse's case abroad.
Where the couple actually lived matters. Matrimonial home, residence and finances will weigh heavily in deciding the convenient forum.
Raise jurisdiction objections in the foreign court itself, as that court decides forum non conveniens for its own proceedings.
Keep Section 13 CPC objections ready for the recognition stage, after a foreign decree is passed.
Ex parte anti-suit injunctions invite counter-orders abroad and can backfire, so seek them only with strong evidence of oppression or vexation.
Build a Career in Family Law and Litigation
Cross-border matrimonial disputes are one of the fastest-growing areas of family practice in India. Handling them well takes more than knowing the law: it takes sharp drafting of divorce petitions, injunction applications, written statements and replies, and a clear sense of which forum and which remedy to choose.
Into Legal World's Advanced Legal Drafting 6.0 course helps law students and lawyers build exactly these skills, with live classes, recorded sessions, a large bank of downloadable drafts, mentorship and placement support.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Can an Indian court stop a divorce case filed abroad?
An Indian court can restrain a party within its jurisdiction from pursuing a foreign case through an anti-suit injunction, but only sparingly. In Mihir Prakash Bajoria vs Vidushi Jain Bajoria (2026 INSC 1034), the Supreme Court refused such an injunction against a UK divorce case.
2. What is an anti-suit injunction?
It is an order directing a party not to start or continue proceedings in another court, including a foreign court. It binds the party, not the foreign court. Under Modi Entertainment Network, the party must be subject to the court's jurisdiction, refusal must defeat justice, and comity must be respected.
3. What is forum non conveniens in divorce cases?
It means a court may decline to hear a case if another forum is more suitable for the parties and the ends of justice. Here, the UK was held to be the convenient forum because the couple's matrimonial home, residence and finances were centred in London.
4. Is a foreign divorce on irretrievable breakdown valid in India?
The Supreme Court did not decide this. Recognition of a foreign decree is tested under Section 13 of the CPC and Y. Narasimha Rao only after the decree is passed. Seeking to block a pending foreign case on this ground was held to be premature.
5. What happened to the UK conditional divorce order?
A UK court passed a conditional divorce order on 17.06.2026 while the appeal was pending. The Supreme Court expressed no opinion on it and left both parties free to challenge that order or any further UK orders before the competent forum.
Get Daily Legal Updates on WhatsApp
Keywords
Mihir Prakash Bajoria vs Vidushi Jain Bajoria, 2026 INSC 1034, anti-suit injunction, anti-suit injunction foreign divorce, NRI divorce India, foreign divorce decree validity in India, forum non conveniens, comity of courts, Section 13 CPC foreign judgment, irretrievable breakdown of marriage, Hindu Marriage Act Section 13, Dinesh Singh Thakur v Sonal Thakur, Modi Entertainment Network, Y Narasimha Rao, UK divorce Indian couple, Supreme Court family law judgment 2026, legal drafting course for law students, family law course for lawyers
Download the Full Judgment





Comments