Supreme Court Reinstates Constable Sacked Over 99-Day Overstay, Rejects Same-Pen Fraud Theory

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on 16 November 2026 ordered the reinstatement of Mithilesh Kumar Pathak, a Constable of the Central Reserve Police Force removed from service for overstaying his leave by 99 days, holding that the enquiry officer's rejection of his medical papers because they seemed to be written with the same pen and had no hospital patient number rested on conjecture and surmise, and that removal was grossly disproportionate. A Bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma (author) and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh set aside the judgment of the Division Bench of the Patna High Court, restored the order of the Single Judge, and granted him 50 per cent of back wages with all other consequential benefits. The judgment is reported as 2026 INSC 1219 and is marked reportable.
The Court held that unauthorised absence and wilful absence are not necessarily synonymous, and that the circumstances, the explanation and the supporting material must be weighed before deciding the nature and gravity of the misconduct.
Case at a Glance
Case: Mithilesh Kumar Pathak v. Union of India and Others
Citation: 2026 INSC 1219 (reportable)
Case Number: Civil Appeal No. 4411 of 2011
Bench: Justice Satish Chandra Sharma (author) and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh
Date of Judgment: 16 November 2026
What Was Challenged: Judgment dated 5 May 2010 of the Division Bench of the High Court of Judicature at Patna in Letters Patent Appeal No. 921 of 2007, which restored the order of 29 March 2001 removing the appellant from service
Outcome: Appeal allowed, Division Bench judgment set aside, Single Judge's order restored, reinstatement with immediate effect with 50 per cent back wages and consequential benefits
The Question Behind the Headline
Can a disciplinary authority disbelieve a constable's medical papers just because the entries look like they were written with the same pen, and then remove him from service for a 99-day overstay? The Supreme Court said no.
Background of the Dispute
The Leave and the Overstay
The appellant was posted with the 54th Battalion of the Central Reserve Police Force at Anantnag, Jammu and Kashmir. He was granted casual leave from 21 September 2000 to 12 October 2000 because his wife was ill, and was due to rejoin on 13 October 2000. He did not, and ignored two registered letters dated 26 October 2000 and 8 November 2000 from the Company Commander directing him to report. He reported for duty on 19 January 2001, overstaying by 99 days.
His Explanation
By an application of 22 January 2001, he said that he himself fell ill on 9 October 2000 in his village in Munger district, Bihar, and was treated for infective hepatitis by Dr. S.N. Singh, a Medical Officer attached to Sadar Hospital, Banka. He relied on prescriptions, pathological reports, receipts for medicines and a certificate declaring him fit for duty on 13 January 2001. He added that his illness, the lack of postal facilities in his village and his wife's inability to read or write stopped him from replying to the letters.
The Enquiry and the Removal
A memorandum of charges dated 25 January 2001 alleged unauthorised absence for 99 days and disobedience of orders in not responding to the two letters. The appellant denied the charges and produced twelve documents.
The Enquiry Officer, on 17 March 2001, held both charges proved. He disbelieved the medical documents mainly because they had no indoor or outdoor patient number, the treatment appeared to be private, and the prescriptions and medicine bills seemed to be written with the same pen, so he inferred they were prepared on the same day and fabricated.
On 29 March 2001, the Commandant imposed the penalty of removal from service with effect from the afternoon of 31 March 2001. The departmental appeal and revision were rejected on 11 January 2002 and 26 March 2004.
The High Court
The Single Judge, on 13 April 2007 in CWJC No. 5308 of 2004, allowed the writ petition, holding that the rejection of the medical documents rested on conjectures and surmises, and quashed the orders of the disciplinary, appellate and revisional authorities. The Division Bench, on 5 May 2010, reversed this, saying the Single Judge had gone beyond judicial review by re-appreciating evidence, that once the absence was unauthorised the plea of illness failed and insubordination was established, that past conduct was relevant to punishment, and that discipline in a uniformed force in a sensitive area must be maintained.
Contentions
For the Appellant
Counsel argued that the Single Judge rightly interfered with findings based on conjecture, that documents cannot be treated as fabricated by reference to the pen or ink or the absence of a hospital registration number without examining the treating doctor, and that earlier overstays had already been dealt with. It was also said that removal was disproportionate and that the enquiry did not comply with Rule 27(c)(4) of the CRPF Rules, 1955, about the opportunity to submit a written statement and lead evidence in defence.
For the Union of India
Counsel said the appellant belonged to a disciplined force posted in a sensitive area, stayed away for 99 days without permission and ignored two directions to report. They contended that the medical papers were procured to justify the overstay, that earlier overstays of 71 days in 1994 and 175 days in 1999 showed repeated disregard of discipline, that adequate opportunity was given in the enquiry, and that the Single Judge substituted his own view of the evidence.
The Supreme Court's Analysis
The Limits of Judicial Review
The Court began with the settled limits of judicial review in disciplinary matters, quoting State of Andhra Pradesh v. S. Sree Rama Rao (1963) and B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India ((1995) 6 SCC 749). A court may interfere where the enquiry violates natural justice or statutory rules, where the authorities were influenced by extraneous considerations, or where the conclusion is so arbitrary and capricious that no reasonable person could reach it. The disciplinary authority is otherwise the sole judge of facts, and a court may mould the penalty if it shocks the conscience.
Unauthorised Absence Is Not the Same as Wilful Absence
The Court held that the Division Bench erroneously set aside the Single Judge's order. Absence without prior permission may be unauthorised, but unauthorised and wilful absence are not necessarily synonymous. The circumstances of the absence, the explanation and the supporting material must be considered before deciding the nature and gravity of the misconduct. Illness or other circumstances beyond an employee's control may be relevant, though they do not automatically excuse the entire period.
The Same-Pen Inference
The Court noted that the Enquiry Officer had questioned the authenticity of the documents because certain entries seemed to be made with the same pen and there was no outpatient number. No verification from the treating doctor, the medical establishment or the pharmacy supported that inference.
Similarity in the writing or ink, without material connecting it to fabrication, could not reasonably sustain the conclusion drawn in the present case.
Missing Patient Numbers and a Private Doctor
The Court accepted that the lack of an indoor or outdoor patient number, and the fact that the doctor treated the appellant privately while using his official seal on the fitness certificate, could call for clarification. These features did not, by themselves, show that no treatment was received or that the documents were forged. The Single Judge was therefore right that the rejection of the medical documents rested on conjectures and surmises.
Removal Was Disproportionate
The Court was conscious that the appellant belonged to a disciplined force posted in a sensitive area, where compliance with orders and timely reporting are essential. Still, punishment must satisfy proportionality. It held that removal from service for overstaying 99 days was unduly harsh, and that even after taking the earlier overstays and the failure to keep in touch into account, the penalty was grossly disproportionate on the facts.
What the Court Did Not Decide
The Court did not rule on the appellant's argument that the enquiry breached Rule 27(c)(4) of the CRPF Rules, 1955, and did not separately discuss the charge of not responding to the two letters. It decided the case on the unsupported rejection of the medical evidence and on proportionality.
The Final Conclusion
The Court set aside the Division Bench judgment and restored the order of the Single Judge, and, in the exercise of its power to mould relief, directed reinstatement with 50 per cent of back wages and all other consequential benefits.
Operative Directions
The appeal is allowed, and the judgment dated 5 May 2010 of the Patna High Court in Letters Patent Appeal No. 921 of 2007 is set aside.
The order dated 13 April 2007 of the Single Judge in CWJC No. 5308 of 2004 is restored.
The respondents shall reinstate the appellant with immediate effect and pay him 50 per cent of the back wages for the period from his removal till reinstatement.
He is entitled to all other consequential benefits, and pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.
Why This Judgment Matters
The reportable judgment is a reminder that findings in a departmental enquiry must rest on evidence, not on suspicion. A disciplinary authority that disbelieves medical papers should verify them with the doctor, the hospital or the pharmacy. A guess about pen, ink or a missing patient number is not enough.
It also confirms that even in a disciplined force, penalty must be proportionate, and that a long overstay does not automatically justify dismissal when an illness is shown. For employees facing charges of overstay, the case shows the value of filing documents early and asking the authority to verify them. For employers, it is a warning to record reasons that connect the evidence to the finding. The back wages were limited to 50 per cent, so relief in such cases is still weighed on the facts.
Upgrade Your Legal Career With the Advanced Legal Drafting Certificate Course
Service and disciplinary cases are won on well-drafted petitions, appeals and representations that attack unsupported findings and show disproportionate punishment. Master petitions, replies, applications and appeals with practical, court-ready training. Enrol in the Advanced Legal Drafting Certificate Course Today
Get Daily Judgment Updates
Join the Into Legal World WhatsApp channel for daily Supreme Court and High Court judgment updates: Join the WhatsApp Channel
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an Enquiry Officer Reject Medical Documents Because They Look Written With the Same Pen?
Not without material connecting the similarity to fabrication. The Supreme Court held that similarity in writing or ink, with no verification from the doctor, hospital or pharmacy, could not reasonably sustain the finding of forgery.
Is Unauthorised Absence the Same as Wilful Absence?
No. The Court held that they are not necessarily synonymous, and the circumstances, the explanation and the supporting material must be considered before judging the nature and gravity of the misconduct.
Was Removal for a 99-Day Overstay Proportionate?
No. Even after considering the earlier overstays and the failure to keep in touch, the Court held that removal from service was grossly disproportionate on the facts.
What Relief Did the Constable Get?
Reinstatement with immediate effect, 50 per cent of back wages from the date of removal till reinstatement, and all other consequential benefits.
Can a Court Interfere With Disciplinary Findings Under Article 226?
Only within limits. A court may interfere where the enquiry breaches natural justice or rules, where extraneous considerations influenced the authority, or where the conclusion is arbitrary and capricious, and it may mould the penalty if it shocks the conscience.
Keywords
Mithilesh Kumar Pathak v. Union of India, 2026 INSC 1219, Central Reserve Police Force constable removal, overstay of leave 99 days, disproportionate punishment, unauthorised absence versus wilful absence, medical documents same pen, conjecture and surmise, judicial review of disciplinary action, B.C. Chaturvedi, S. Sree Rama Rao, back wages 50 per cent, Justice Satish Chandra Sharma, Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh, Supreme Court judgment 16 November 2026
Case Title: Mithilesh Kumar Pathak v. Union of India and Others
Case No.: Civil Appeal No. 4411 of 2011
Citation: 2026 INSC 1219
Bench: Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh




Comments