Bombay HC Freed Two UAPA Accused on Default Bail Over One Word, “Only” — Supreme Court Reverses It (2026 INSC 1021)
A UAPA charge sheet, a fifteen-day extension, and one disputed word in a trial court's order, "only" - that was all it took for the Bombay High Court to order two accused persons released on default bail. The Supreme Court has now reversed that order, and in doing so has clarified exactly how much weight a single word in a judicial order should carry.
The Case: An Alleged Conspiracy and a Missed Custody Deadline
On 21 September 2022, the Anti-Terrorism Squad (ATS), Mumbai, registered an FIR against five named persons under Sections 120B, 121A and 153A of the IPC and Section 13(1)(b) of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 (UAPA), alleging a conspiracy to spread propaganda and disaffection against the country. Two of the accused, Momin Moiuddin Gulam Hasan and Asif Aminul Hussain Khan Adhikari, were arrested on 22 September 2022. Under Section 43D of the UAPA, the investigating agency gets up to 180 days (in phases of 90 + 90) to file a charge sheet, well beyond the ordinary 60/90-day limit under Section 167 CrPC.
Two Extensions, and a Word That Changed Everything
As the first 90-day period neared its end, the Special Judge granted a first extension of 30 days on 17 December 2022, citing two grounds: pending forensic (FSL) data retrieval and pending government sanction for prosecution. The order used the phrase "on that ground only" while discussing the FSL ground. A second extension of 15 days followed on 18 January 2023, for the same reasons plus further data analysis. The accused's default bail application, filed the same day, was rejected as premature.
The respondents challenged both extension orders before the Bombay High Court, arguing that the Special Judge's own words, "on that ground only", meant sanction was never accepted as a valid reason for extension. If sanction was not a valid ground, they argued, the second extension was illegal, their custody had crossed the permissible period, and they were entitled to be released on default bail as an indefeasible right under Article 21.
The Bombay High Court's Ruling
The High Court agreed with the accused. It held that Section 45 of the UAPA requires sanction only for the court to take cognizance, not for the police to file a charge sheet, and that once the prosecution itself stated "there is enough evidence to file a charge sheet", the investigation had to be treated as complete. On that reading, seeking extension merely to await sanction was, in the High Court's words, not a "legal and valid ground", so the second extension order was illegal and an indefeasible right to default bail had accrued to the accused on 19 January 2023, the day the first extended period expired.
The Supreme Court's Correction: Read the Order as a Whole
A two-judge Bench of Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Shree Chandrashekhar disagreed, and the reasoning is a lesson in how courts should read orders. The word "only" in the first extension order, the Bench held, could not be lifted out of context and treated as if the trial judge had rejected the sanction ground altogether. Read as a whole, the order granted 30 days because retrieval of forensic data was itself sufficient, while sanction remained an additional, live reason. "A sentence in an order or a judgment cannot be lifted out of its context and interpreted in a manner that defeats the logic behind the decision," the Court observed, adding that a document has to be read as a whole, not in piecemeal.
The Court also rejected the High Court's finding that the investigation was already complete merely because the prosecution's extension application said "there is enough evidence to file a charge sheet." A single line pleaded to justify urgency, the Court held, cannot be treated as an admission that the entire investigation, including collation of electronic and financial evidence, had concluded.
Sanction Is for Cognizance, Not for Filing the Charge Sheet
The judgment reaffirms a settled distinction: under Section 45 of the UAPA and Section 196 CrPC, the embargo is on the court taking cognizance without sanction, not on the police filing a charge sheet. Relying on its own earlier rulings in Judgebir Singh @ Jasbir Singh Samra vs NIA (2023) 17 SCC 48 and Suresh Kumar Bhikamchand Jain vs State of Maharashtra (2013) 3 SCC 77, the Court held that investigation is deemed complete once a charge sheet with supporting material is filed, regardless of whether sanction has come through or cognizance has been taken. It also relied heavily on State of NCT of Delhi vs Raj Kumar @ Lovepreet @ Lovely (2024) 2 SCC 632, which involved near-identical facts, pending sanction and a pending FSL report, and upheld the extension.
Why Default Bail Exists, and Where Courts Draw the Line
The Court traced the constitutional roots of default bail to Article 21, citing Bikramjit Singh vs State of Punjab (2020) 10 SCC 616 for the proposition that once an accused applies for default bail before the charge sheet is filed, the right becomes indefeasible regardless of how the application is later decided. It also surveyed comparable custody-time-limit regimes in the UK, the US, Germany, Canada and New Zealand, none of which have an exact equivalent of India's default bail mechanism, to underline that the balance Indian courts must strike is between personal liberty and the practical realities of investigating serious offences like terrorism, which routinely involve voluminous electronic and financial evidence.
But that liberty-protective purpose, the Court held, does not mean every extension is fair game either: an extension can only be granted while investigation is genuinely ongoing, and only for want of time to investigate, not to await an administrative sanction that has nothing to do with completing the probe. On the facts here, the investigating agency was still verifying bank statements, analysing seized electronic devices, and processing voice samples through the forensic lab, so the investigation itself was demonstrably incomplete.
The Final Verdict
The Supreme Court set aside the Bombay High Court's judgment dated 15 July 2024, upheld the Special Judge's second extension order dated 18 January 2023 as legal and valid, and dismissed the respondents' default bail application. Respondent No. 1 was directed to surrender within 30 days, with liberty to seek regular bail on merits before the trial court.
Why This Case Matters for Law Students and Lawyers
This judgment is essential reading for anyone drafting bail applications, extension pleas, or replies under special statutes like UAPA, NDPS or MCOCA: it shows exactly how courts parse the wording of a trial court's order, how the sanction-versus-cognizance distinction is applied in practice, and how a single sentence in a pleading can be misread if taken out of context. Precision in legal drafting, and precision in reading the drafting of others, is exactly what ILW's Advanced Legal Drafting 6.0 course is built to train, covering bail applications, criminal pleadings, and courtroom-ready drafting across 12 practice areas. Explore the course here.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What did the Supreme Court decide in State of Maharashtra vs Momin Moiuddin Gulam Hasan?
The Court set aside the Bombay High Court's order granting default bail to two UAPA accused, holding that the trial court's second extension of time for filing the charge sheet was legal, since the investigation was genuinely incomplete when it was granted.
2. Can a UAPA charge sheet be delayed to wait for government sanction?
Not on its own. Sanction is required only for the court to take cognizance, not for the police to file the charge sheet. An extension of time to file the charge sheet must be justified by incomplete investigation, not merely by a pending sanction order.
3. What is default bail under Section 167 CrPC and Section 43D UAPA?
Default bail is an accused person's indefeasible right to be released on bail if the investigating agency fails to file a charge sheet within the statutory period. For UAPA offences, Section 43D extends the ordinary 60/90-day limit up to a maximum of 180 days, in phases, where the court is satisfied with the progress reported.
4. Does filing a charge sheet without sanction affect an accused's right to default bail?
No. Once a charge sheet with the material collected is filed within the statutory period, the investigation is deemed complete for the purposes of Section 167 CrPC, whether or not sanction for prosecution has been obtained or cognizance has been taken.
5. How should courts interpret ambiguous wording in a trial court's order?
The Supreme Court held that a single word or sentence in an order cannot be read in isolation. The document must be read as a whole, in the context of the facts and reasons before the court, rather than parsed for a literal but misleading meaning.
Read the full Supreme Court judgment (2026 INSC 1021).
Original source (Google Drive): https://drive.google.com/file/d/1glTbUccA5Yhzg7zMJzwa4CIEx0Mmrpq5/view?usp=sharing
For more Supreme Court case analyses and ILW course updates, join our WhatsApp channel.
Keywords: UAPA default bail India, Section 43D UAPA extension charge sheet, Section 167 CrPC default bail, sanction for prosecution UAPA Section 45, State of Maharashtra vs Momin Moiuddin, Bombay High Court UAPA bail reversed

