top of page

Supreme Court Gives JK Paper Two Months to Deposit Rupees Fifteen Crore More or Face Execution of Rupees Sixty-Seven Crore Land Compensation Warrant; Rejects Gorge Defence

Oct 7
7 min read

New Delhi, 7 October 2026: The Supreme Court of India has directed M/s JK Paper Ltd to deposit an additional Rupees Fifteen Crore with the Registrar General of the Gujarat High Court within two months, failing which the High Court's stay on the enhanced land acquisition award and on execution proceedings will stand revoked. A Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu also rejected the company's claim that a gorge (nala) running through the 34.72 acres at Village Gunsada had reduced the useful land, and left every other dispute, including when the company actually received possession, to the High Court in the pending first appeals.

Case at a Glance

  • Case Title: M/s JK Paper Ltd v. Bipinchandra Natwarlal Shah and Others, with Bipinchandra Natwarlal Shah and Others v. M/s JK Paper Ltd and Another

  • Citation: 2026 INSC 1095 (Non-Reportable)

  • Bench: Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu (order authored by Justice Datta)

  • What Was Challenged: The common order dated 30 June 2025 of the Gujarat High Court at Ahmedabad on stay applications in First Appeal No. 2489 of 2023

  • Arising From: Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 21774 of 2025 and Special Leave Petition (Civil) Nos. 23751-52 of 2025

  • Date of Order: 7 October 2026

  • Counsel: Mr. Gopal Sankaranarayanan, Senior Counsel, for the company; Mr. Maninder Singh, Senior Counsel, for the landowners; Ms. Deepanwita Priyanka for the State of Gujarat

Background: A 2005 Acquisition and a Rupees 950 Per Square Meter Award

Proceedings to acquire Block No. 207 of Village Gunsada, measuring 1,40,504 square meters (about 34.72 acres), were started under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 for the benefit of JK Paper. The Special Land Acquisition Officer valued the land at Rupees 124 per square meter. On the landowners' reference, the Reference Court by its award dated 23 February 2023 raised the value to Rupees 950 per square meter, together with a 12 percent escalation, solatium at 30 percent, and interest at 9 percent for the first year and 15 percent for the later period, reckoned from receipt of possession.

Both sides appealed to the Gujarat High Court. The landowners want Rupees 1,500 per square meter in First Appeal No. 1653 of 2023, while the company attacks the Rupees 950 valuation in First Appeal No. 2489 of 2023. Both appeals are still pending. In the meantime, the Executing Court issued a warrant on 23 May 2025 to recover Rupees 67,48,34,981 from the company, to be held by that court subject to the outcome of the first appeals.

What the Gujarat High Court Had Ordered

By its common order of 30 June 2025, the High Court stayed the award and the execution proceedings on conditions. Working at Rupees 950 less the Rupees 124 already paid, it computed additional compensation of Rupees 826 per square meter and a total, with interest, of Rupees 63,92,88,361. The company was told to deposit 50 percent of the awarded additional compensation with solatium, price rise and interest within two months. Half of the deposit could be withdrawn by the landowners against security, and the other half was to sit in a cumulative fixed deposit till the appeal is decided. The company has told the Supreme Court it has so far deposited Rupees 9,33,33,744.

The Number Nobody Is Talking About: Three Quarters of It Is Interest

The High Court's own table, reproduced in the Supreme Court's order, shows that the basic compensation with solatium and price rise comes to about Rupees 16.48 crore. Interest adds roughly Rupees 47.45 crore (Rupees 1.48 crore at 9 percent and Rupees 45.97 crore at 15 percent up to 19 November 2024). On those figures, about 74 percent of the Rupees 63.93 crore total is interest. The High Court had noted that the company disputes liability for interest for the period when status quo orders kept it out of the land, and called it a highly disputed question of fact on which there was no evidence at that stage.

Issue One: Did the Company Get Possession of All 34.72 Acres?

At an early stage, the company told the Supreme Court it had not been given possession of about 24.77 acres. By an order dated 4 November 2025, the Court directed delivery of possession. The State of Gujarat has since stated on affidavit that, as on 10 November 2025, the Mamlatdar handed over the remaining 24.77 acres, the company having till then purportedly possessed only 9.95 acres. The Bench recorded that possession of the entire subject land now appears to be with the company.

Issue Two: The Gorge (Nala) and Waterlogging Plea

The company argued that a gorge (nala) running through the land caused waterlogging and cut down the useful area. After looking at the record, including the company's letter of 6 July 2026 to the Mamlatdar, the Bench had no hesitation in rejecting this. It held that the company knew of the gorge, the waterlogging and other encumbrances from the time acquisition began, and that it was too late in the day to complain, since the acquisition for its benefit began as far back as 2005. The company has been barred from raising this issue again before the High Court.

Issue Three: Why the Court Left Disputed Facts to the High Court

The Bench found several other disputed questions of fact, among them when the company first came into possession of the land or part of it, and to what extent. These, it said, must be examined by the High Court and will affect the final compensation payable. Relying on Malluru Mallappa (Dead) v. Kuruvathappa and Others, (2020) 4 SCC 313, which describes a first appeal as a continuation of the original proceedings open to full reconsideration on facts and law, the Court said it was loath to exercise its jurisdiction under Article 136 and act as a fact-finding court.

The Directions: Rupees Fifteen Crore, Two Months, and a Stay on the Line

  • The High Court's stay continues for two months.

  • The company must deposit an additional Rupees 15 crore with the Registrar General of the High Court within two months, without prejudice to the rights and contentions of both sides in the first appeals.

  • If it fails to deposit, the stay on the award and on execution stands revoked, and the landowners are free to pursue their claim before the Executing Court.

  • If it deposits, the stay continues until the High Court orders otherwise.

  • The Registrar General must invest the amount in a short-term interest-bearing fixed deposit with a nationalised bank on auto renewal.

  • The High Court is requested to expedite both first appeals, bearing in mind that the acquisition dates back to 2005 and that possession of about 24.77 acres was delivered on 10 November 2025. Apart from the gorge issue, all points stay open.

The Question the Order Leaves Open

The order does not say in terms whether the Supreme Court's Rupees 15 crore direction replaces or sits on top of the High Court's 50 percent condition. Our reading, on the figures recorded, is this: the Rupees 9.33 crore already deposited plus Rupees 15 crore comes to about Rupees 24.33 crore, whereas 50 percent of the High Court's Rupees 63.93 crore figure would be about Rupees 31.96 crore. If the old condition no longer applies, the company's stay is now secured by a smaller sum than the High Court had set. If it still applies, the order is silent on how the two directions fit together. This is an analysis of the numbers, not a finding in the order, and the High Court may be asked to clarify it.

What It Means Going Forward

Who Is Affected

For Beneficiary Companies

Defects in the land that were visible when acquisition began will not help when compensation is being fixed. Stays in large land acquisition awards come with a price in the form of deposits.

For Landowners

Execution is paused, not ended. The deposit sits with the High Court's Registrar General, and the Rupees 1,500 per square meter claim remains alive in First Appeal No. 1653 of 2023.

For the Gujarat High Court

It must now decide, on evidence, when possession was really taken and how that moves the interest component, which is the largest part of the claim.

Practitioner Note

The order is a clear reminder that the Supreme Court will not use Article 136 to settle disputed facts that a first appellate court is yet to decide.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What did the Supreme Court decide in M/s JK Paper Ltd v. Bipinchandra Natwarlal Shah?

It disposed of the appeals against the Gujarat High Court's stay order by continuing the stay for two months, directing JK Paper to deposit an additional Rupees 15 crore with the High Court's Registrar General, rejecting the company's gorge (nala) plea, and leaving all other disputes to the High Court in the pending first appeals.

2. How much must JK Paper deposit and by when?

An additional Rupees 15 crore must be deposited with the Registrar General of the Gujarat High Court within two months of 7 October 2026. The company says it has already deposited Rupees 9,33,33,744.

3. What happens if JK Paper does not deposit the amount?

The High Court's stay on the award and on execution proceedings stands revoked, and the landowners can pursue their claim before the Executing Court.

4. Why did the Supreme Court reject the gorge (nala) argument?

The Bench found that the company knew of the gorge, waterlogging and other encumbrances from when acquisition proceedings began in 2005 for its own benefit, so raising it now was too late. The company cannot raise it before the High Court.

5. Has the Supreme Court fixed the final land compensation?

No. The Reference Court's Rupees 950 per square meter valuation is under challenge by both sides in First Appeal Nos. 2489 of 2023 and 1653 of 2023, which the High Court has been requested to decide quickly. Disputed facts such as the date of possession remain open.

Keywords

JK Paper Supreme Court land acquisition, JK Paper Bipinchandra Natwarlal Shah, 2026 INSC 1095, Village Gunsada land acquisition, Gujarat High Court land compensation stay, Supreme Court deposit Rupees 15 crore, enhanced compensation stay conditions, Land Acquisition Act 1894 compensation, gorge nala land acquisition, Article 136 disputed questions of fact, Justice Dipankar Datta land acquisition, land acquisition law course

Build a Career in Land, Property and Compensation Law

Disputes like this one, over valuation, possession, interest and security for stays, are the daily work of property and real estate lawyers. To learn how to handle title, due diligence, drafting and regulatory work in this field, join our Certificate Course on Real Estate Law: RERA, TPA, Drafting, Due Diligence and Insolvency at Into Legal World.

For daily judgment updates, join the Into Legal World WhatsApp channel.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes and is not legal advice. It analyses a non-reportable order, and the figures quoted are as recorded in it. Please read the order before relying on it.

Case Title: M/s JK Paper Ltd v. Bipinchandra Natwarlal Shah and Others

Case No.: Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 21774 of 2025, with Civil Appeals arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 23751-52 of 2025 | 2026 INSC 1095

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page