top of page

Supreme Court Restores Dredging Award, Says 70% Extra Work Cannot Shock Conscience

13 minutes ago
8 min read
Supreme Court Restores Dredging Award, Says 70% Extra Work Cannot Shock Conscience - Justice J. B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on 18 November 2026 restored an arbitral award in favour of dredging contractor Marino Dredgeco Limited against the Board of Trustees of the Port of Kolkata, holding that the Calcutta High Court could not cut the award by half on the sole ground that the additional work exceeded 70 per cent of the original contract value and shocked its conscience. A Bench of Justice J. B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran (author) set aside the Division Bench judgment under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and allowed the contractor's appeal. The judgment is reported as 2026 INSC 1238 and is marked non-reportable.

The Court held that a court under Section 37 cannot modify an award by using the words shocking the conscience without a substantive reason. It also held that a Government entity gets no special treatment, and that the Division Bench never looked at the measurements and invoices behind the award.

Case at a Glance

  • Case: M/s Marino Dredgeco Limited v. The Board of Trustees of the Port of Kolkata

  • Citation: 2026 INSC 1238 (non-reportable)

  • Case Numbers: Civil Appeal No. 14303 of 2026 (arising out of Special Leave Petition (C) No. 15175 of 2025) with Civil Appeal No. 14304 of 2026 (arising out of Special Leave Petition (C) No. 40370 of 2026, Diary No. 50150 of 2025)

  • Bench: Justice J. B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran (author)

  • Date of Judgment: 18 November 2026

  • What Was Challenged: Judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court at Calcutta under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, which cut the arbitral award to 50 per cent and reduced interest to 6 per cent

  • Outcome: Contractor's appeal allowed, impugned judgment set aside, arbitral award restored, the Port's appeal disposed of

The Question Behind the Headline

Can a court cut an arbitral award in half just because the bill for extra work looks too big, when it finds the award is not perverse, not based on no evidence and not patently illegal? The Supreme Court said no.

Background of the Dispute

The Dredging Contract

The original contract was for dredging the river bed and shores at Sagar Island to make an approach channel and basin for a shore-based pilot station, to be completed within 18 months. The total payable for the original work was ₹2,86,56,200, of which ₹2,79,32,865 had been paid. The work was in use from 17 April 2001, when the Chairman of the Port Trust inaugurated the pilot station using the channel dredged by the contractor.

The Additional Work

By a letter dated 19 July 2000, the Port Trust entrusted additional work to the contractor. The contractor said that the additional work was needed because of 100 per cent siltation, which required repeated dredging, since the Port Trust did not give correct data about the soil and did not build protective walls. The arbitration was started for this additional work, and the award is dated 3 November 2003.

The Courts Below

  • The learned Single Judge, under Section 34, affirmed the arbitral award.

  • The Division Bench, in the Port Trust's appeal under Section 37, recorded that the award could not be called one based on no evidence or insufficient evidence, nor perverse, patently illegal or against the fundamental policy of Indian law.

  • Even so, because the additional work claimed was more than 70 per cent of the original contract amount, the Division Bench said it shocked its conscience and fell within conflict with the basic notions of morality or justice. It cut the amounts payable to 50 per cent of what the arbitrator quantified and reduced interest to 6 per cent on the principal from 8 February 2002.

Contentions

For the Contractor

Senior Advocates Mr. R. Anand Padmanabhan and Mr. Amitava Mukherjee argued that the original contract was for dredging a channel and basin, and the additional work was identical re-dredging. They said that the powers under Section 37 are limited, as held by the Constitution Bench in Gayatri Balasamy v. M/s ISG Novasoft Technologies Limited (2025 INSC 605), and that the modification rested on a subjective presumption that additional work cannot reach a large percentage of the original value, without looking at the nature of the work.

For the Port Trust

Senior Advocate Mr. Siddharth Bhatnagar sought setting aside of the entire award, or in the alternative upholding the 50 per cent reduction with 6 per cent interest. He said that no completion certificate was issued, no additional work was entrusted, and the contractor failed to procure the certificate of completion required under the General Conditions of Contract. He relied on Gayatri Balasamy to say the whole award should have been set aside as against public interest, and on Batliboi Environmental Engineers Ltd. v. Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. (2024) 2 SCC 375 to argue that quantification should not result in a windfall.

The Supreme Court's Analysis

The Additional Work Was Real and Admitted

The Court noted that the work was completed by 17 April 2001, and that the letter of 19 July 2000 showed the additional work was required. The work was delayed by adverse force majeure conditions not attributable to the contractor, and the additional work was necessitated by force majeure weather and by non-compliance of the soil character with the data supplied by the Port Trust itself. Re-dredging was identical in nature to the original contract.

The Missing Completion Certificate

The Court pointed out that the Division Bench itself recorded that the certificate was not available because the Port Trust did not issue it, and that the refusal to issue it does not stop the contractor from claiming the bill for work carried out. The contractor produced the measurements, the award rested on pre-work and post-work levels, and the documents were not irrelevant. The Court therefore found no basis for modification on the ground of shocking the conscience.

What the Law Allows Under Section 37

The Court looked at Ssangyong Engineering & Construction Co. Ltd. v. National Highways Authority of India (2019) 15 SCC 131, which held that conflict with the most basic notions of morality or justice applies only where the award shocks the conscience of the Court, and that the words are not to be applied as lip service. There must be a substantive reason which blatantly and patently shows the conflict.

Merely for reason of refusal to issue completion certificate, it cannot be said that the contractor would not be entitled to the amounts in the bill raised for the work carried out.

Mere Labels Are Not Enough

Relying on Somdatt Builders-NCC-NEC (JV) v. National Highways Authority of India (2025) 6 SCC 757, the Court said a court under Section 37 cannot set aside an award by merely using expressions like opposed to the public policy of India, patent illegality or shocking the conscience. The impugned order used those words on the sole ground that the bills exceeded 70 per cent of the original contract, without looking at the nature of the additional work.

No Partial Setting Aside

Gayatri Balasamy allows an award to be set aside in part, but not where the valid and invalid portions are legally and practically inseparable or intertwined. Here, the quantification rested on valid measurements and invoices for one kind of work, re-dredging, which cannot be split into valid and invalid parts. The Division Bench had not looked at the measurements or invoices, which would anyway amount to an adjudication on the merits that the Act prohibits.

No Special Treatment for a Government Entity

The Court noted that the Division Bench expressed shock at the size of the claim partly because the awarder is a State entity. Citing Pam Developments Private Ltd. v. State of West Bengal (2019) 8 SCC 112, it said parties to an arbitration must be treated equally, and that the quantum decided by the arbitrator on valid material cannot be disturbed only because the award debtor is a Government entity and the sum appears excessive, when no such ground was raised against the award itself.

Batliboi Did Not Apply

The Court said that Batliboi, relied on by the Port Trust, dealt with damages and not with invoices validly raised for additional work, so it had no application.

The Final Conclusion

The reasoning of the Division Bench was not in consonance with the grounds on which an arbitral award can be set aside, especially as the arbitrator had looked at documents on the joint measurements of the additional work entrusted to the contractor.

Operative Directions

  • The impugned judgment of the Division Bench is set aside, and the contractor's appeal is allowed.

  • The arbitral award stands restored.

  • The Port Trust's appeal is disposed of, since the impugned order is already set aside in the contractor's appeal.

  • Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.

Why This Judgment Matters

The ruling guards the narrow limits of Section 37 appeals. Judges cannot use shocking the conscience as a shortcut to review the merits of an award. They must give a substantive reason, and the size of a claim relative to the original contract is not enough without looking at the nature of the work.

For contractors, the case shows that measurements, invoices and the awarder's own letters entrusting extra work are powerful evidence, and that a refusal to issue a completion certificate does not wipe out payment for work done. For Government bodies, it is a warning that they will be treated like any other party in arbitration, and for lawyers, a reminder to attack an award on the grounds the Act allows. The case also shows how long this dispute ran: the work was completed in 2001, the award is of 2003, and the final decision came in 2026.

Upgrade Your Legal Career With the Advanced Legal Drafting Certificate Course

Arbitration awards are won and defended on well-drafted claims, replies and challenge petitions. Master petitions, replies, applications and appeals, including objections under Sections 34 and 37, with practical, court-ready training. Enrol in the Advanced Legal Drafting Certificate Course Today

Get Daily Judgment Updates

Join the Into Legal World WhatsApp channel for daily Supreme Court and High Court judgment updates: Join the WhatsApp Channel

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a Court Cut an Arbitral Award Because It Shocks the Conscience?

Only if there is a substantive reason that blatantly shows conflict with the most basic notions of morality or justice. The Supreme Court held that using the words as lip service, solely because additional work exceeded 70 per cent of the original contract, is not enough.

Does a Missing Completion Certificate Defeat a Contractor's Claim for Extra Work?

Not necessarily. The Court held that the Port Trust's refusal to issue the certificate does not by itself stop the contractor from claiming the bill for work actually carried out, which was backed by joint measurements.

Is a Government Entity Treated Differently in Arbitration?

No. Relying on Pam Developments v. State of West Bengal, the Court said parties must be treated equally and the quantum cannot be reduced just because the award debtor is a Government entity.

Can a Court Under Section 37 Modify an Award by Half?

Not on the ground used here. The Court held that the valid and invalid portions cannot be separated when the quantification is based on one kind of work, and a court cannot re-examine the measurements and invoices, since that would be an adjudication on the merits.

What Happens to the Arbitral Award Now?

The arbitral award of 3 November 2003 in favour of Marino Dredgeco Limited stands restored in full.

Keywords

Marino Dredgeco Limited v. Board of Trustees of the Port of Kolkata, 2026 INSC 1238, Section 37 Arbitration and Conciliation Act, shocking the conscience arbitral award, Gayatri Balasamy v. ISG Novasoft, Ssangyong Engineering v. NHAI, Somdatt Builders v. NHAI, Pam Developments v. State of West Bengal, additional work dredging award restored, partial setting aside of award, Justice J. B. Pardiwala, Justice K. Vinod Chandran, Supreme Court judgment 18 November 2026

Case Title: M/s Marino Dredgeco Limited v. The Board of Trustees of the Port of Kolkata

Case No.: Civil Appeal No. 14303 of 2026 with Civil Appeal No. 14304 of 2026

Citation: 2026 INSC 1238

Bench: Justice J. B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page