top of page

Can a Contract Clause Stop an Arbitrator From Awarding Interest? Supreme Court Says Yes (2026 INSC 1036)

Sep 22
8 min read

Updated: Sep 25

Imagine winning your case. An Arbitral Tribunal finds that the delay on a power project was entirely the employer's fault, awards you Rs. 3.30 crore, and adds 12% interest for the years you were kept out of your money before arbitration even began. Then, almost three decades after the work was first tendered, the Supreme Court takes that interest away.

Not because the contractor lost on merits. Not because the delay was its fault. But because of a single sentence in a standard form contract signed in 1996. That is the story of North Eastern Electric Power Corporation Limited (NEEPCO) vs Astra Construction Private Limited, decided on 22 September 2026 (2026 INSC 1036), and it is a judgment every arbitration lawyer, contractor and public sector legal team should read closely.

The Case at a Glance

  • Case: North Eastern Electric Power Corporation Limited (NEEPCO) vs Astra Construction Private Limited

  • Citation: 2026 INSC 1036 (Non-Reportable), Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (Civil) No. 24803 of 2025

  • Bench: Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe (judgment authored by Justice Alok Aradhe)

  • Date of Judgment: 22 September 2026

  • Under Challenge: Judgment of the High Court of Meghalaya at Shillong dated 19.06.2025 in an appeal under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996

  • Core Question: Does Clause 54 of the General Conditions of Contract (GCC) stop an Arbitral Tribunal from awarding pre-reference interest?

  • Result: Appeal allowed. The grant of pre-reference interest was set aside.

Four Forums, Four Different Answers

This dispute climbed almost every rung of the arbitration ladder, and the answer on interest kept changing at each step.

  • 12.06.1995: NEEPCO invites tenders for the civil works of the main plant and auxiliary building of a Gas Turbine Power Project at Ram Chandra Nagar, Tripura.

  • 23.05.1996: Agreement signed with Astra Construction. Estimated value Rs. 17,09,26,913. Work to be completed by 26.03.1997.

  • 05.06.2015 (Arbitral Tribunal): Delay held attributable to NEEPCO. Four claims allowed, principal of Rs. 3.30 crore awarded, with 12% per annum pre-reference interest and 9% per annum pendente lite and future interest.

  • 15.02.2024 (Commercial Court, Section 34): Relying on Sayeed Ahmed, held that Clause 54 bars both pre-reference and pendente lite interest. Interest on claim nos. 2, 3, 4 and 5 set aside; rest of the award upheld.

  • 19.06.2025 (High Court of Meghalaya, Section 37): Relying on Harish Chandra, held Clause 54 was identical to the clause considered there and only barred interest on money held up due to a dispute. Award restored in its entirety.

  • 22.09.2026 (Supreme Court): Clause 54 bars pre-reference interest. The High Court judgment set aside to the extent it restored that interest.

The Sentence That Decided Everything: Clause 54 of the GCC

Titled "No Claim for Delayed Payment due to Dispute Etc.", the clause reads:

"No claims for interest or damages will be entertained by the Corporation with respect to any money or balance which may be lying with the Corporation owing to any dispute, difference or misunderstanding between the Engineer-in-Charge on the one hand and contractor on the other or with respect to any delay on the part of the Engineer-in-Charge making periodical or final payments or in any other respect whatsoever."

Read quickly, it looks like routine boilerplate found in almost every public works contract in India. Read carefully, as the Supreme Court did, it contains two separate bars, not one.

Harish Chandra vs Sayeed Ahmed: How a Few Extra Words Changed the Outcome

The High Court restored interest because it treated Clause 54 as identical to the clause interpreted by a three-Judge Bench in State of U.P. v. Harish Chandra and Co., (1999) 1 SCC 63. The Supreme Court disagreed, and the whole difference lies in how the two sentences are built.

  • The Harish Chandra clause: It barred interest on money lying with the Government owing to a dispute or misunderstanding between the Engineer-in-charge "in making periodical or final payments". Those payment words only described where the dispute arose. They did not create a new ground. So interest arising purely from late payment, with no dispute at all, was never covered, and the arbitrator could still award it.

  • Clause 54 in this case: It bars interest in two independent situations joined by the word "or". First, money lying with the Corporation because of a dispute. Second, "any delay on the part of the Engineer-in-Charge making periodical or final payments". Then comes the sweep-up phrase "or in any other respect whatsoever".

By naming delay in payment as a standalone ground, Clause 54 does exactly what the Harish Chandra clause never did: it shuts out interest arising from delayed payment whether or not there was any dispute. The Court found the same structure in the clauses examined in Sayeed Ahmed & Company v. State of U.P., (2009) 12 SCC 26 and Jaiprakash Associates Ltd. v. Tehri Hydro Development Corporation (India) Ltd. (THDC-II), (2019) 17 SCC 786, where such clauses were treated as a complete bar on interest. Put simply, the Court held that different wording produces a different legal result, and the Sayeed Ahmed line, not Harish Chandra, governs this contract.

Why Pre-Reference Interest Stands on a Different Footing

Under the old regime: The Arbitration Act, 1940 had no provision allowing arbitrators to award interest. A Constitution Bench filled that gap in Secretary, Irrigation Department, Government of Orissa v. G.C. Roy, (1992) 1 SCC 508, presuming interest to be an implied term unless the contract forbade it. Contractual bars were construed strictly and against the party relying on them.

Under the 1996 Act: Section 31(7)(a) gives the tribunal power to award interest, but opens with the words "Unless otherwise agreed by the parties". Relying on Pam Developments Pvt. Ltd. v. State of West Bengal, (2024) 10 SCC 715, the Court explained that party autonomy now prevails: an express bar in the agreement is enough to exclude the power, even if it is not specifically addressed to the arbitrator.

The key distinction: Pendente lite interest is procedural and governed by Section 31(7)(a). Pre-reference interest is substantive. It cannot come from Section 31(7)(a) alone and must rest on the parties' agreement, a statute such as Section 3 of the Interest Act, 1978, or proof of mercantile usage. The Court reaffirmed this, also noting ONGC v. G & T Beckfield Drilling Services. So once the contract itself bars interest, there is simply nothing left to support a pre-reference award.

The Two Arguments That Failed

1. Waiver: Astra Construction, through senior counsel Ritin Rai, argued that NEEPCO never raised Clause 54 before the Tribunal and had therefore waived it, relying on Union of India v. Susaka Pvt. Ltd., (2018) 2 SCC 182. The record said otherwise: NEEPCO had specifically taken the plea in its Statement of Defence filed on 23.08.2012. The argument collapsed.

2. Narrow reading and fairness: Intervenors, through senior counsel C.S. Vaidyanathan, argued that the bar covers only interest on money lying with the employer and not other heads such as damages, that "or in any other respect whatsoever" takes colour from the words before it, and that a wider reading would make the clause one-sided, arbitrary and constitutionally impermissible. The Court held that the contention that Clause 54 mirrors the Harish Chandra clause was without merit.

Is This Fair? The Debate This Judgment Will Reignite

This is where the ruling becomes genuinely controversial, and both sides have a real case.

  • The case for the ruling: The contractor signed the contract. The 1996 Act deliberately elevates party autonomy. Consistent reading of standard clauses gives certainty to thousands of public works contracts, and the judgment simply follows the settled Sayeed Ahmed and THDC-II line.

  • The case against: General Conditions of Contract are drafted by the employer and offered on a take-it-or-leave-it basis. Here, the contractor proved the delay was NEEPCO's fault, yet bears the cost of its money being held back for years before arbitration began. Critics will ask whether such clauses reward the very delay they are meant to manage.

The judgment is marked non-reportable, so it does not create new law. But it firmly reinforces the Sayeed Ahmed line and is likely to be cited wherever a similarly worded interest bar appears in a government or PSU contract.

What Actually Survives for the Contractor

NEEPCO, represented by Solicitor General Tushar Mehta and Additional Solicitor General Raghavendra P. Shankar, confined its challenge to pre-reference interest alone. The Supreme Court set aside the High Court judgment only to the extent it restored pre-reference interest. The rest of the High Court's decision was not disturbed in this appeal, and there was no order as to costs.

Practical Lessons for Lawyers, Contractors and PSUs

  • Read the interest clause before drafting the claim. Check whether it bars only interest on withheld money, or also interest on delayed payments.

  • Compare the wording line by line with the clauses in Harish Chandra, Sayeed Ahmed and THDC-II. A single "or" can decide crores.

  • For employers: plead the contractual bar in the Statement of Defence. That single pleading defeated the waiver argument here.

  • For contractors: raise interest-bar clauses at the pre-bid stage. Once the contract is signed, courts will enforce the words as written.

  • Remember the source rule: pre-reference interest needs a contractual, statutory or mercantile-usage basis. Section 31(7)(a) alone will not sustain it.

Want to Argue Cases Like This? Build Your Career in Arbitration

NEEPCO vs Astra Construction shows how one clause, one line of precedent and one well-drafted Statement of Defence can swing crores in an arbitration. Law firms, PSUs, infrastructure companies and arbitral institutions are actively looking for lawyers who can spot these details early.

Into Legal World's Advanced Certificate Course in Arbitration & Dispute Resolution is built for law students and practising lawyers who want exactly these skills: reading and drafting arbitration and interest clauses, framing claims and defences, and handling challenges under Sections 34 and 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What did the Supreme Court decide in NEEPCO vs Astra Construction (2026)?

The Supreme Court held that Clause 54 of the GCC bars pre-reference interest, and that the Arbitral Tribunal exceeded its jurisdiction under Section 31(7)(a) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 by awarding it. The High Court of Meghalaya's judgment was set aside to the extent it restored that interest.

2. What is pre-reference interest in arbitration?

It is interest for the period from when the cause of action arose until the dispute is referred to arbitration. It is a matter of substantive law, so it must be based on the contract, a statute such as Section 3 of the Interest Act, 1978, or mercantile usage, and cannot rest on Section 31(7)(a) alone.

3. Can an arbitrator award interest if the contract prohibits it?

Generally no. Section 31(7)(a) applies "unless otherwise agreed by the parties". Following Sayeed Ahmed, THDC-II and Pam Developments, an express contractual bar excludes the tribunal's power to award pre-reference and pendente lite interest, even if the bar is not addressed specifically to the arbitrator.

4. What is the difference between Harish Chandra and Sayeed Ahmed?

The Harish Chandra clause barred interest only on money held back because of a dispute, so interest for pure delay in payment remained open. The clauses in Sayeed Ahmed and THDC-II, like Clause 54, add a separate bar on interest for delayed payments, which makes them a complete bar on interest.

5. Can a party lose the right to rely on an interest bar by not raising it before the tribunal?

Astra Construction argued waiver, relying on Union of India v. Susaka Pvt. Ltd. The Court rejected it because NEEPCO had specifically raised Clause 54 in its Statement of Defence dated 23.08.2012. The practical lesson is to plead such bars at the earliest stage.

Get Daily Legal Updates on WhatsApp

Keywords

NEEPCO vs Astra Construction, 2026 INSC 1036, pre-reference interest in arbitration, Section 31(7)(a) Arbitration and Conciliation Act, Clause 54 GCC, interest bar clause, Harish Chandra vs Sayeed Ahmed, THDC-II, Pam Developments, pendente lite interest, public works contract arbitration, Supreme Court arbitration judgment 2026, arbitration course for law students, arbitration career for lawyers

Download the Full Judgment



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page