Supreme Court Condemns GST Accused's Forum Shopping, Yet Lets Interim Bail Stand
NEW DELHI, October 16, 2026: The Supreme Court has strongly deprecated the conduct of a GST fraud accused who ran bail and release proceedings in parallel before the Sessions Court and the Karnataka High Court while keeping each forum in the dark, calling it an abuse of the process of law. Yet a Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu did not send him back to jail. It held that the High Court's bail order may not be set aside at this stage, revived his bail petition for fresh consideration by the same Single Judge, and kept him on interim bail meanwhile. The reason: the Court found the department had also been unable to put its case before the High Court.
Case at a Glance
Case: Senior Intelligence Officer, Directorate General of GST Intelligence v. Mohammed Kamran
Citation: 2026 INSC 1140 (reportable)
Court and Bench: Supreme Court of India, Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu (order authored by Justice Datta)
Challenged: Order dated 26 December 2025 of a Single Judge of the Karnataka High Court in Criminal Petition No. 16884 of 2025 granting bail
Decided on: October 16, 2026
Outcome: Appeal disposed of; criminal petition revived before the Single Judge; respondent to remain on interim bail; counter affidavit in two weeks; decision preferably by the end of 2026
Background: The Rs. 43 Crore GST Complaint
The Senior Intelligence Officer, Directorate General of Service Tax Intelligence, filed a private complaint before the Special Court for Economic Offences, Bengaluru, against Mohammed Kamran. The complaint alleges offences under Section 16(2)(b) read with Sections 132(1)(b), 132(1)(c) and 132(1)(f) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, recorded in the judgment as punishable under Section 135. The allegation is that Kamran, proprietor of M/s MK Traders, issued invoices without supply of goods, availed fraudulent input tax credit, and falsified documents and financial statements to evade tax, causing a loss of Rs. 43,08,22,936. The department also alleged that during a search at his declared and actual residences he offered stiff resistance and fled, and that a separate FIR was registered for that.
Timeline of Events
16.09.2025: Kamran is arrested. Successive bail applications before the trial court and the Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge are rejected.
09.12.2025: He files a criminal petition seeking bail before the High Court.
10.12.2025: He files a similar bail application before the Sessions Court, which is rejected while the High Court petition is pending (the fourth rejection in the series).
12.12.2025: The High Court petition is first listed. The department is directed to file objections within two weeks.
20.12.2025: The High Court's winter vacation begins.
22.12.2025: He files Writ Petition No. 38771 of 2025 challenging the legality of his arrest, seeking quashing of the complaint and cognizance order, and interim release. The ad-interim prayer is refused. Later that day, a memo seeking listing of the bail petition is allowed.
26.12.2025: During the vacation, the Single Judge grants bail.
07.07.2026: The writ petition is dismissed.
10.09.2026: The Supreme Court allows the department to file an additional affidavit and Kamran to reply.
Who Argued What
The department: Mr. N. Venkataraman, learned Additional Solicitor General, argued that the High Court should not have heard the petition when an adjournment was sought because the arguing counsel was absent, that the counsel who appeared had no instructions to contest on merits, and that natural justice was violated. He also said Kamran never disclosed the refusal of ad-interim relief in the writ petition, and urged that a litigant who abuses the process of law be dealt with firmly.
Mohammed Kamran: Mr. S. Nagamuthu, learned senior counsel, said the plea about the arguing counsel's absence was never taken before the Single Judge, that the counsel who appeared first faintly sought an adjournment and then addressed the Court on merits, and that the department failed to file objections within two weeks. On merits, he cited the gravity of allegations, long incarceration of more than nine months, completed investigation, the offences being Magistrate triable, and a maximum punishment of five years.
Issue 1: Was the Department Denied a Hearing?
Ordinarily the Court said it would have dismissed the special leave petition at the outset, but notice was issued because of the grievance that the department was not heard and because the issue concerned judicial propriety and uberrima fides. The Court examined the affidavits, the video recording and the transcript of the 26 December 2025 hearing. It found merit in Kamran's point that the department's counsel present in court did advance some submissions on merits, but accepted that counsel had also asked for an adjournment because the Standing Counsel had been engaged. Its conclusion:
"While on the one hand, it would not be entirely correct to claim that the appellant was wholly unrepresented before the Single Judge, on the other it stands to reason that the appellant could not be represented by its Standing Counsel."
Issue 2: Forum Shopping and Suppression of Material Facts
This is where the Court turned on the accused. It said what bothered it was the conduct of the respondent and the manner in which he moved the High Court for expedited hearing. It recorded that he had pursued bail and release before the Sessions Court and in the writ petition while the High Court bail petition was pending, and that the rejection by the Sessions Court and the refusal of release by the writ court were not brought to the High Court's notice.
"Respondent's conduct in pursuing such parallel remedies, while keeping all judicial authorities in the dark, must be severely deprecated. It may be a right of the accused to challenge his arrest or to approach a court seeking bail; however, such conduct of pursuing remedies parallelly, particularly without adequate disclosure, clearly amounts to abuse of the process of law."
The Court held that the respondent had suppressed material facts and indulged in suppressio veri and suggestio falsi, and that there was a clear lack of uberrima fides, which it called the foundation for invoking the equitable and discretionary jurisdiction for bail. It agreed that the Additional Solicitor General was justified in calling him crafty and disingenuous. It also noted that the department had failed to file its objections, perhaps because the time was too short, and that the vacation and the lack of notice of the listing memo meant neither the department nor its counsel could bring all facts before the Single Judge.
Issue 3: Listing a Bail Petition During Vacation
The Court held that, in view of the earlier direction, the petition should ideally have been listed after the High Court reopened, since it was not returnable on a specific date within the vacation nor directed before the Vacation Bench. Obtaining listing without adequate notice to the department was, in its words, clearly an attempt to steal a march by even misleading the Court.
The Result: Why Bail Was Not Cancelled
The Court added that had it been a case of arrest for a heinous offence, it would have taken a very strict view of the respondent's conduct. Having regard to the entire turn of events, it held that the High Court's bail need not be set aside at this stage, but the matter needed fresh consideration. It set aside the part of the order disposing of the criminal petition, so that the petition revives on the High Court's file. Instead of the bail granted by the Single Judge, the respondent remains on interim bail on the earlier terms and conditions.
Counter affidavit: The department may place all materials on record by a counter affidavit within two weeks, peremptorily.
Rejoinder: The respondent has one week to file his rejoinder.
Decision: The Single Judge will decide the criminal petition on its own merits, preferably by the end of this year.
Interim bail: It operates until further orders of the Single Judge on the criminal petition.
Guidance on Vacation Listing
Before parting, the Court made observations on urgent listing before a high court Bench during vacation. Where a Bench directs listing "two weeks hence" and the day after expiry of that period falls in the midst of a vacation, the registry should ordinarily compute the two weeks excluding the vacation period. If the petition is made returnable on a specific date during the vacation or the Bench directs listing before the Vacation Bench, it should ideally be listed accordingly, subject to the relevant high court rules. The Court said these observations aim at uniformity and ensuring that litigants are not prejudiced by an inadvertent act of the court.
What the Court Did Not Do
It did not cancel the respondent's liberty. He stays on interim bail.
It did not decide the merits of the GST fraud allegations or the bail itself. That is for the Single Judge.
It did not decide the pending writ-related issues beyond noting that the writ petition was dismissed on 7 July 2026.
What It Means Going Forward
For Accused and Their Counsel
Disclose every pending and decided bail or release proceeding, including refusals of interim relief. Parallel remedies without disclosure can be treated as abuse of process and forum shopping, and may cost the accused the benefit of equitable relief.
For Investigating Agencies and Standing Counsel
Counsel must be properly instructed and objections filed when directed. The Court noted the department's failure to file objections, even though it excused it on the facts.
For High Courts and Registries
Vacation listing of bail matters needs care: compute "two weeks" excluding vacation, and list urgent matters before the Vacation Bench where directed.
Learn Criminal Law and Bail Practice
If you want to learn how bail petitions, disclosures and writ remedies are drafted and argued, explore our Certificate Course in Criminal Law Drafting and Litigation at Into Legal World. For daily judgment analysis, join our WhatsApp channel.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did the Supreme Court cancel Mohammed Kamran's bail?
No. It set aside the part of the High Court order that disposed of the bail petition, revived the petition, and directed that he remain on interim bail on the earlier terms until the Single Judge decides the matter afresh.
What did the Court mean by forum shopping in this case?
The respondent pursued bail or release before the Sessions Court and in a writ petition while his High Court bail petition was pending, without telling the High Court that the Sessions Court had rejected bail and that the writ court had refused interim release.
Was the GST department denied a hearing in the High Court?
Partly. The Court found the department's counsel did make some submissions on merits, but its Standing Counsel could not appear, and the department could not place all material on record because of the short time and the vacation listing.
What is the alleged GST loss in this case?
The complaint alleges fake invoicing without supply of goods and fraudulent input tax credit by M/s MK Traders, causing a loss of Rs. 43,08,22,936.
What did the Court say about listing matters during vacation?
Where a direction to list "two weeks hence" ends during a vacation, the period should ordinarily be computed excluding the vacation. If the petition is returnable on a specific date during vacation or is directed to the Vacation Bench, it should be listed accordingly, subject to high court rules.
Keywords
Supreme Court, Senior Intelligence Officer v. Mohammed Kamran, 2026 INSC 1140, GST fraud bail, forum shopping, abuse of process of law, suppression of material facts, interim bail, uberrima fides, vacation listing, Karnataka High Court, input tax credit, Section 483 BNSS
Read the judgment: Download the judgment PDF | Source link (Google Drive)
Case Title: Senior Intelligence Officer v. Mohammed Kamran
Case No.: Criminal Appeal arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 7504 of 2026
Citation: 2026 INSC 1140
Bench: Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu





Comments