Tax Department Stuck With Rupees 1.35 Lakh, Supreme Court Rejects Late Appeal
The Supreme Court has dismissed the Central Tax department's appeal against a resolution plan as barred by limitation, holding that the 45-day period to appeal under Section 62 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code runs from the date the NCLAT pronounces its order, not from whenever a party chooses to collect a certified copy. The appeal was filed 16 days beyond the absolute outer limit of 60 days.
The stakes made the delay costly. The department had lodged a claim of Rs. 22,60,32,948 against the corporate debtor, M/s Samyu Glass Private Limited. The resolution plan approved by the NCLT, and confirmed by the NCLAT, set aside just Rs. 1,34,657 towards the excise arrears. With the appeal dismissed on limitation, the Supreme Court never reached the merits of that gap.
A Bench of Justice S.V.N. Bhatti and Justice N.V. Anjaria rejected the department's argument that limitation began only when it received the certified copy, warning that such a reading would make the right of appeal subject to an indefinite and fluctuating period of limitation.
Case at a Glance
Case Title: The Assistant Commissioner of Central Tax, CGST Division v. Sreenivasa Rao Ravinuthala and Another
Citation: 2026 INSC 1121 (Reportable)
Case No.: Civil Appeal No. 7882 of 2023
Bench: Justice S.V.N. Bhatti (author) and Justice N.V. Anjaria
What Was Challenged: NCLAT Chennai order dated 02.08.2023 in Company Appeal (AT) (CH) (INS) No. 346 of 2021, confirming the resolution plan approved by NCLT Hyderabad on 13.08.2021
Date of Judgment: 14 October 2026
Outcome: Preliminary objection on limitation upheld; appeal dismissed as time-barred; merits not examined
Background: A Rs. 22.6 Crore Claim and a Rs. 1.35 Lakh Plan
Samyu Glass Private Limited, an Export Oriented Unit making glass containers, faced several central excise recovery proceedings between 2013 and 2017 and stopped manufacturing around late 2016. It challenged the demands before CESTAT. Andhra Bank, now Union Bank of India, initiated insolvency under Section 7 of the IBC, and Respondent No. 1 was appointed Resolution Professional.
When the department convened a pricing committee on 04.11.2019 to auction attached machinery, the Resolution Professional told it that the moratorium barred any disposal of assets. On 27.11.2019, the department filed a claim in Form F for Rs. 22,60,32,948. The Resolution Professional also approached the department under the Sabka Vishwas (Legacy Dispute Resolution) Scheme, 2019, presenting a settlement of Rs. 4,32,80,741.
On 13.08.2021, NCLT Hyderabad approved a resolution plan providing Rs. 1,34,657 towards the excise arrears. The department appealed, but the NCLAT confirmed the plan on 02.08.2023. The department filed its appeal before the Supreme Court on 21.11.2023, and Respondent No. 2 raised a preliminary objection on limitation.
The Clash Over When the Clock Starts
The Department: Time Runs From Receipt of the Order
Counsel for the department argued that Section 62(1) allows an appeal within 45 days "from the date of receipt of such order", and that this differs deliberately from the language of Section 61. Since the certified copy was received on 11.10.2023 and the appeal filed on 21.11.2023, it was within 41 days and in time.
The Respondent: Sixty Days Is the Outer Limit
Senior Advocate Ritin Rai argued that the IBC is a complete code with strict timelines: 45 days plus a condonable 15 days. Counted from 03.08.2023, the outer limit expired on 01.10.2023, and the appeal was filed on the 111th day. Even excluding the period between applying for the copy on 06.09.2023 and receiving it on 11.10.2023, the appeal had to be filed by 05.11.2023.
What the Supreme Court Held
The Clock Starts at Pronouncement
Relying on Rule 91 of the NCLAT Rules, 2016, under which reading the operative portion in open court is deemed pronouncement, the Court held that knowledge and limitation commence on the date the NCLAT pronounces its order. The phrase "from the date of receipt of the order" cannot mean the date a party chooses to apply for and collect a certified copy.
If the Appellant's argument that the limitation period begins on the day the copy of the Order is received is accepted, it would nullify both the limitation period and the condonable period, and make the right of Appeal subject to an indefinite and fluctuating period of limitation.
Only the Time Requisite for the Copy Is Excluded
Under Section 12(2) of the Limitation Act, applied through Section 238-A of the IBC, only the time between applying for the certified copy and the copy being ready is excluded. Under the Explanation to Section 12, any inaction before applying counts against the litigant. The Court noted that if limitation did not begin on pronouncement, Section 12(2) would become redundant.
Why Sagufa Ahmed Did Not Help the Department
The Court distinguished Sagufa Ahmed v. Upper Assam Plywood Products, where limitation under Section 421(3) of the Companies Act ran from receipt because the NCLT Rules created a right to a free certified copy. The IBC, as held in V. Nagarajan v. SKS Ispat, is a complete code that overrides the Companies Act, and for Supreme Court appeals the Supreme Court Rules, 2013 place an affirmative duty on the appellant to apply for and file a certified copy. Following CA Ramchandra Dallaram Choudhary v. Adani Infrastructure, the Court reiterated that 60 days is the absolute ceiling under Section 62.
The 16-Day Arithmetic
02.08.2023: NCLAT pronounces its order; limitation begins.
06.09.2023: Department applies for a certified copy on the 35th day; these 35 days count against it.
06.09.2023 to 11.10.2023: 35 days taken to prepare the copy, excluded under Section 12(2).
21.10.2023: The remaining 10 days of the 45-day period expire.
05.11.2023: The further 15 condonable days expire; the Court's power to condone ends.
21.11.2023: Appeal filed, 41 days after receiving the copy.
Adding the 35 days before applying and the 41 days after receipt gives 76 days, against an absolute ceiling of 60. The appeal was 16 days beyond the outer limit, and the Court sustained the preliminary objection and dismissed the appeal without costs.
What It Means Going Forward
No Exception for the State
This reportable judgment applies the IBC's strict timelines to the revenue department as firmly as to any private creditor. The practical lesson is blunt: the limitation clock under Section 62 starts in the courtroom on the day of pronouncement, and every day before a copy is applied for is a day lost. Once 60 days pass, no sufficient cause can save the appeal, however large the claim.
For Government Departments and Creditors
Track NCLAT cause lists, apply for a certified copy immediately after pronouncement, and treat 45 days as the real deadline, with 15 days only as an emergency buffer.
For Resolution Professionals and Successful Applicants
A time-barred challenge to an approved plan can be defeated at the threshold through a preliminary objection, without the Court going into merits.
For Insolvency Practitioners
Calculate limitation from pronouncement, document the date of the copy application and the date the copy was ready, and remember that the Supreme Court Rules cannot extend the IBC's outer limit.
Master Insolvency Practice With Into Legal World
From filing claims in Form F to challenging resolution plans within strict timelines, insolvency practice rewards precision. Learn it through ILW's Insolvency and Restructuring Practice course.
For daily judgment updates and career opportunities, join the Into Legal World WhatsApp Channel.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the Supreme Court hold in Assistant Commissioner of Central Tax v. Sreenivasa Rao Ravinuthala (2026 INSC 1121)?
The Supreme Court dismissed the tax department's appeal under Section 62 of the IBC as time-barred, holding that limitation runs from the date the NCLAT pronounces its order and that the appeal was filed 16 days beyond the absolute 60-day limit.
When does limitation start for an appeal to the Supreme Court under Section 62 IBC?
It starts on the date the NCLAT pronounces the order. Only the time actually taken to prepare a certified copy after it is applied for is excluded under Section 12(2) of the Limitation Act.
What is the maximum time to appeal to the Supreme Court under the IBC?
45 days, extendable by up to 15 days on sufficient cause, making 60 days the absolute outer limit. Beyond that, the Supreme Court cannot condone delay.
Does delay in applying for a certified copy count against the appellant?
Yes. Under the Explanation to Section 12 of the Limitation Act, time before the application for a copy is made cannot be excluded. Here, the 35 days before the department applied counted against it.
Did the Supreme Court approve the Rs. 1,34,657 payout to the tax department on merits?
No. The appeal was dismissed only on limitation, so the Court did not examine whether the amount provided in the resolution plan was fair. The NCLAT's confirmation of the plan stands.
Keywords
Section 62 IBC limitation, appeal to Supreme Court IBC 45 days, 2026 INSC 1121, Assistant Commissioner Central Tax v Sreenivasa Rao Ravinuthala, Samyu Glass resolution plan, Section 12(2) Limitation Act certified copy, NCLAT pronouncement limitation, V Nagarajan v SKS Ispat, condonation of delay IBC 60 days, tax department insolvency claim
Read the Full Judgment
Case Title: The Assistant Commissioner of Central Tax, CGST Division v. Sreenivasa Rao Ravinuthala and Another
Case No.: Civil Appeal No. 7882 of 2023
Citation: 2026 INSC 1121
Bench: Justice S.V.N. Bhatti and Justice N.V. Anjaria





Comments